Some great images and a great post for sure, Neil!
however, I would not recommend buying these photographs for the following reasons:
Magnum, once a cooperative of like minded photographers, now has external commercial investors and therefore financial interests at heart. Magnum Photos is in the business of making money. The Square Prints is a great way for them to do so. At £110 each for a tiny 6” x 6”/ 15 cm x 15 cm print, this may seem reasonable. From a collector's perspective, I suggest you think carefully.
There are three kinds of prints:
Estate Prints: The photographer is dead and someone else, sometimes family, sometimes not, are now in charge. There are no guard rails and no rules for how many and how big or small they can be, or indeed what quality they have. BAD
Stamped Prints: These are stamped by Magnum on behalf of the photographer, who is still alive, but may be too frail, or away working somewhere, where they cannot sign. The photographer therefore did not approve the quality of the print. BETTER
Signed Prints: These are signed by the photographer. BEST
My concern with all the Magnum Square Prints is the number made of each print. The sale is available for 7 days. There is a sense of urgency imposed by Magnum, but they do not say how many prints will be made, not before and not after (I have asked). For all we know, there could be thousands of each…..
You may have noticed there are no Henri Cartier-Bresson photographs on offer in the sale. He is one of the founders of Magnum, maybe THE most important of them all, so why not? Henri Cartier-Bresson wrote in his will that prints could not be made unless under his supervision, and not after he died. There are no estate prints. That should tell you something.
In my opinion, unless these photographs are purely for decoration, and you don’t care about what you pay for them, I would recommend against them. Buy the postcard instead. A postcard is a few $/€/£ and once framed will be about the same size as the Magnum Square Prints, and you will be hard pressed to tell the difference, and you will have saved yourself some money.
I always remind myself that French Customs declare anything in an edition greater than 25 a poster, and we are buying photographs here, not posters. This would make these prints postcards 😃
This is not a slight on the photographs, but merely my 5-cents worth!
I did say something back in the Spring. I just don’t like the idea of people moving on these without a good picture of what is really happening.
I do think photojournalist and therefore Magnum members are in a tough spot. Many quit with the new ownership. They thought they had lost their freedom to self assign projects, which I also wholeheartedly agree with. It is difficult times.
I am not sure where the profits from these sales go? But, that is for another day.
Some great images and a great post for sure, Neil!
however, I would not recommend buying these photographs for the following reasons:
Magnum, once a cooperative of like minded photographers, now has external commercial investors and therefore financial interests at heart. Magnum Photos is in the business of making money. The Square Prints is a great way for them to do so. At £110 each for a tiny 6” x 6”/ 15 cm x 15 cm print, this may seem reasonable. From a collector's perspective, I suggest you think carefully.
There are three kinds of prints:
Estate Prints: The photographer is dead and someone else, sometimes family, sometimes not, are now in charge. There are no guard rails and no rules for how many and how big or small they can be, or indeed what quality they have. BAD
Stamped Prints: These are stamped by Magnum on behalf of the photographer, who is still alive, but may be too frail, or away working somewhere, where they cannot sign. The photographer therefore did not approve the quality of the print. BETTER
Signed Prints: These are signed by the photographer. BEST
My concern with all the Magnum Square Prints is the number made of each print. The sale is available for 7 days. There is a sense of urgency imposed by Magnum, but they do not say how many prints will be made, not before and not after (I have asked). For all we know, there could be thousands of each…..
You may have noticed there are no Henri Cartier-Bresson photographs on offer in the sale. He is one of the founders of Magnum, maybe THE most important of them all, so why not? Henri Cartier-Bresson wrote in his will that prints could not be made unless under his supervision, and not after he died. There are no estate prints. That should tell you something.
In my opinion, unless these photographs are purely for decoration, and you don’t care about what you pay for them, I would recommend against them. Buy the postcard instead. A postcard is a few $/€/£ and once framed will be about the same size as the Magnum Square Prints, and you will be hard pressed to tell the difference, and you will have saved yourself some money.
I always remind myself that French Customs declare anything in an edition greater than 25 a poster, and we are buying photographs here, not posters. This would make these prints postcards 😃
This is not a slight on the photographs, but merely my 5-cents worth!
Super informative! I think you said something similar back in March, but not in so much detail.
If I were going to buy something, it would be to support Magnum as a thing in the world, which — external investors or not — still does good work.
I tend to agree with you on the perils of post-death printing: https://crop.photography/p/the-living-dead
I did say something back in the Spring. I just don’t like the idea of people moving on these without a good picture of what is really happening.
I do think photojournalist and therefore Magnum members are in a tough spot. Many quit with the new ownership. They thought they had lost their freedom to self assign projects, which I also wholeheartedly agree with. It is difficult times.
I am not sure where the profits from these sales go? But, that is for another day.
Have you read the financials? https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/01932412/filing-history